Ford Takes New Jersey to Court Over What It Pays Dealers for Recall Work
Ford and three other automakers want a federal judge to throw out a New Jersey law that lets dealers bill carmakers retail prices for warranty and recall repairs.
Ford and three other automakers want a federal judge to throw out a New Jersey law that lets dealers bill carmakers retail prices for warranty and recall repairs.
Honda, Volkswagen and Stellantis, through its FCA unit, joined Ford in the complaint, which was filed in Trenton on Friday, November 20. The law at issue, formally the Fair Compensation Act and in force since April 1, links what a manufacturer owes for covered repairs to what the same dealer charges customers who pay out of pocket.
In the filing, as Reuters described it, the companies say New Jersey has given franchised dealers "unilateral, unchecked power" over what manufacturers pay for warranty, recall and other service, and has left them no way to avoid what they call the "extortionate" outcome or to make the money back.
Governor Phil Murphy signed the measure, Assembly bill A4380 and Senate bill S3309, in September 2025, CBT News reported at the time. A client alert from the law firm Fox Rothschild lays out how it works. A dealer sets its warranty labor rate and parts markup from a sample of its own customer-paid repair orders, either 100 in a row or 90 days’ worth, whichever is fewer, and the new rate takes effect 30 days after the dealer declares it. The manufacturer may audit only that sample. Dealers can also replace the factory’s flat-rate time guide with a multiplier drawn from the hours they actually bill retail customers.
The law reaches further than rates. It covers the cost of vehicles held under stop-sale and do-not-drive recall orders, bars manufacturers from cutting a dealer’s incentives or charging back claims in retaliation for warranty and recall filings, and freezes a disputed chargeback without bond while the dealer challenges it in court. It also lets dealer groups such as the New Jersey Coalition of Automotive Retailers sue on behalf of their members.
For Ford owners in New Jersey, the fight is about who absorbs the cost of fixing their trucks and SUVs under warranty. Ford dealers there are entitled to bill Ford at retail-level rates for that work, and the companies’ complaint argues the bill has no ceiling they can control.
The Ford Insider Take
This is a fight over leverage more than labor rates. A law that lets the dealer set its own warranty price from its own retail tickets, and limits the factory’s audit to the tickets the dealer picked, is about as dealer-friendly as these rules get, so it is no surprise four automakers chose this one to test in federal court. Ford has a lot riding on the answer, because every recall repair it pays for in New Jersey is now billed at retail. Owners should not notice anything at the service desk, but if laws like this hold up, that money has to come from somewhere, and the most likely place is the price of the next car.


